Here are all of our member and editor comments about Carnegie Deli (The Mirage).

On May 22 2007, Lynn Holliday wrote:

We enjoyed our meal at Carnegie Deli.
Everything is huge, and paying the $3 to share a plate is not a bad idea. We didn’t manage to finish more than half of anything.

Comparing with an earlier visit, both my son and I agreed that the pastrami is much more delicious than the corned beef which we found dry.

The dessert portions are just as huge as everything else – again, sharing might be the order of the day.

Our server was attentive and cheerful and we felt we received good value for the money … which would have been improved even further if we’d had the foresight to share instead of ordering individual plates.

On April 16 2007, Doug Shimrak wrote:

If you like authentic deli sandwiches, this is as good as it gets. Quality ingredients and prepatation, and they’re huge.

On May 26 2006, RateVegas.com User wrote:

Carnegie Deli was great – TRY THE PASTRAMI…

On November 23 2005, RateVegas.com User wrote:

Poor service and mediocre food. Bears little relationship to the original Carnegie Deli in Midtown Manhattan, which is too bad

good idea but poor execution.

On May 16 2005, RateVegas.com User wrote:

Matzo ball soup was the worst I’ve ever had. A family of New Yorkers at the next table agreed. It tasted more like grits than a matzo ball. I mentioned that it was awful to the hostess on the way out. She smiled and said “I know”.

The waiter was reasonably attentitive but was clearly unfamiliar with the menu.

Ready to share your own comments? Click here to get started!